How we calculate

What we calculate with, where the data comes from and how recent it is, and where our calculation stops.

In short

  1. We read the price, the capacity, the power and the promised savings from your quote. You check them.
  2. We build your electricity use and solar production hour by hour for a whole year: from your meter file, or estimated from your yearly use, your solar panels and your postcode.
  3. We let the battery run through that year, hour by hour, under the rules for 2026 (net metering) and from 2027 (no more net metering), including its losses and standby use.
  4. We compare what you save with the price, and do the same for the batteries on our list that fit your home.

Data sources

The date shows how recent the data is that we calculate with.

Data sources and their dates
SourceWhat we use it forDate
ENTSO-E and Energy-Charts.infoHourly electricity market prices for the Netherlands (dynamic contracts, battery planning)31 December 2025
PVGIS (European Commission)Solar production per hour in a typical year for your region31 December 2023
NEDUThe standard household usage profile, scaled to your yearly use31 December 2025
KNMI and Open-MeteoOutdoor temperatures for the heat pump calculation–
BelastingdienstEnergy tax, ODE and VAT per year (2027: the Tax Plan proposal)1 January 2026
Municipality of AmstelveenThe 2026 heat pump grant: amount, conditions and deadline30 September 2026
RVOThe national heat pump subsidy (ISDE) and its list of models30 September 2026
Shops and manufacturersPrices and specifications of the batteries on our list30 September 2026
CBS (Statistics Netherlands)Average consumer gas and electricity prices per month, and how they changed per year31 October 2026

Price data: ENTSO-E; Energy-Charts.info (Fraunhofer ISE), data Bundesnetzagentur | SMARD.de, CC BY 4.0

Energy prices

For gas and electricity on a fixed or variable contract we use the national average CBS publishes every month (table 85592NED: all running contracts, new and old together). New contracts often cost more, so you can fill in your own price; we then use that. The latest month is October 2026: gas cost €1.42 per m³ and electricity €0.27 per kWh on average, including energy tax and VAT. With a dynamic contract we use the hourly prices of the electricity market.

Nobody knows what prices will be in 2027 and later. We assume today's price; the range shows how much it can differ. For that range we take how the price without tax changed over every 12-month period since January 2018 (before 2021 from CBS table 84672NED): from the lowest 10% to the highest 10% of changes. Then we add that year's energy tax and VAT.

Change of the price without tax after 12 months
Price and periodLow (P10)Middle (P50)High (P90)
Gas, all years0.70×0.97×2.87×
Gas, without 20220.78×0.93×1.18×
Electricity, all years0.77×0.96×2.66×
Electricity, without 20220.77×0.94×1.28×

With the 2022 energy crisis included, the top of the range is so wide (the price without tax almost three times as high) that no payback can be calculated from it. So for the range we use the years without 2022. A new crisis is not ruled out, but it is not in the range. We show the middle in the table, but don't calculate with it: we assume today's price.

The energy tax for 2027 comes from the 2027 Tax Plan. It is still a proposal; we update it once it is law.

A price has a delivery period, a time when we retrieved it, and sometimes a verified publication time. These are different. Complete historical prices do not prove that a controller knew them in advance. We retain revisions and actual observation times; unknown historical publication stays unknown. The 2025 Dutch reference prices come from Energy-Charts.info (Fraunhofer ISE), data Bundesnetzagentur | SMARD.de, under CC BY 4.0. We convert EUR/MWh to EUR/kWh and average native prices over each hour for the household calculation. After the October 2025 change to quarter-hour prices, this assumes uniform flow within each hour.

Data up to 31 October 2026.

How we rank alternatives

We rank by payback time: the price divided by what the battery saves per year from 2027, among the batteries that fit your connection (1 or 3 phases) and type (plug-in or installed). The battery with the shortest payback comes first. What we earn never changes the order, and products without a shop link are ranked the same way.

Savings over the chosen period

The lifetime indication adds declared yearly savings, subsidies and investment over the chosen period. Discounting values later amounts in today’s money. The displayed financial scenario holds the 2027 saving constant; it assumes no additional supplier trading income or equipment replacement. Short or incomplete meter periods cannot become measured whole years in this calculation.

A fall in future cash savings is a financial sensitivity assumption. Physical ageing needs a new calculation with each year’s declared usable capacity, power and losses. Our separate research tools support such equipment scenarios; the displayed constant-savings indication does not measure ageing, predict replacement downtime or establish a heat pump’s future efficiency.

Day-ahead savings and imbalance trading

With a dynamic contract, the main battery savings and payback calculation includes buying electricity in cheaper hours and using or exporting it in dearer hours, alongside storing your solar power. We assume next-day prices become available at 13:00 Dutch time. Earlier plans end tonight; from 13:00 they extend through tomorrow. Historical publication is not verified for each price. Household demand and solar production are assumed known within that window. The separate forecasting research has not replaced this reference calculation.

We check imbalance-trading promises against available historical 15-minute settlement prices. Those prices are not advance trading signals. A hindsight optimum and an assumed 16–28% capture range give a historical stress estimate, not measured trading income, gross before supplier fees or revenue sharing. We do not add it to household savings, payback or lifetime value: the same battery serves both uses.

If you select a supplier, we show its dated sources, conditions and any unknown eligibility or payout terms. Missing essential terms make supplier income unavailable; a supplier name or an app’s indicative amount does not establish future earnings. We do not attach an assumed supplier fee to the generic capture range.

Separate research can settle one physical battery’s joint home and market actions on a shared interval ledger. A working controller that combines day-ahead and imbalance trading still needs advance signals, eligible equipment and complete settlement rules. The quote check does not infer that income from two separate simulations. Historical data coverage and missing usable prices remain visible in each trading check.

What forecasting research shows

We tested battery policies in preselected winter, spring, summer and autumn weeks from four Dutch development homes, using only completed meter history for forecasts. The seasonal forecast did not consistently beat simpler policies or no battery. These finite-week tests have not changed the quote calculation or its coefficients. A separate comparison retains shorter meter intervals to show how hourly aggregation changes simulated battery use; it does not establish actual trading income.

Fixed-price scenarios and scenarios with assumed price publication are reported separately. Verified historical price availability is still missing. Repeated weeks from these homes do not meet our independent validation gate of 30 Dutch households.

Why other calculators often come out higher

Does another calculator or a quote come out higher than we do? That is usually down to one of these four assumptions.

  • Perfect foresight. Our dynamic-contract planner assumes normal afternoon publication of next-day prices, rather than knowing a whole year in advance. It still assumes demand and solar production are perfectly known within its planning window. The separate imbalance stress estimate assumes 16–28% of the hindsight optimum; imbalance prices are not published one day ahead.
  • No standby draw and no ageing over time. A battery uses some electricity itself, even when idle, and it wears out even when it charges little. Leave that out and you get a battery that is never replaced in 25 years. We include each product’s declared or assumed standby draw. A chosen financial horizon does not establish equipment life; ageing and replacements need explicitly stated scenarios.
  • Only the rules from 2027. Until the end of 2026 net metering applies, and a battery then earns little. Showing only the rules from 2027 shows a saving you don't get in 2026 yet. We show both years separately.
  • Without saying what was assumed. A figure without its price, efficiency and rules can't be checked. With every result we show what it rests on and what we measure and estimate.

How we earn money

EnergieNuchter takes no money from installers, sellers or energy suppliers. Sometimes we show a shop link for an alternative that comes out better than your quote. If you buy through it, we get a fee, and the amount is shown next to the link. If you come via an energy advice desk, you see no such links. Read more under who pays for this.

Which shops we check (not complete)

This list is not complete. We check a small number of shops, by hand or from a feed, and only where a shop allows it. A buy link goes to the cheapest shop with stock among these, on the date shown next to it.

Shops and sources we check for prices
ShopHowHow often
AEGby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
batterijenhuis.nlby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Budget Thuisby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Frank Energieby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
HomeWizardby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Marstekby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
My Green Energyby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
NextEnergyby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Quattby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Sessyby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Solar-Outletby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
solarpowersupply.nlby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
thuisbatterij.nlby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
voordeelshop.ah.nlby hand, for the cataloguemonthly
Zendureby hand, for the cataloguemonthly

Limits

  • We calculate with prices and weather from the past. The future will be different, so we show a range where we can.
  • Without a meter file, your use per hour is an estimate. Battery planning assumes demand and solar production are known within the planning window.
  • The household calculation uses hourly steps; the separate imbalance stress test uses 15-minute prices. Shorter peaks are not visible.
  • Trading checks use available historical prices. Each report shows the coverage and says when usable data are missing.
  • We only check what is on the quote and what you tell us. We do not see your meter cupboard, roof or inverter.

The disclaimer says what the result does and does not mean.

For installers

Do you sell batteries or heat pumps and do you think a result about your quote is wrong? Send us the figures from the quote and your own calculation at installateurs@energienuchter.nl. We reply within 10 working days. If we made a mistake, we correct the calculation for every result and say so in our changelog. We don't change a result because a seller disagrees with our assumptions; those are published under 'How we calculate'.

Changes

Every change to how we calculate or to the products and prices we compare with, with its date. Results calculated earlier are recalculated when the calculation changes.

  1. Calculation The separate imbalance-trading estimate now uses the stated usable battery capacity without deducting another 10% reserve. Rounding can no longer enlarge that capacity. Electricity-bill savings remain separate from this trading estimate.
  2. Products and prices A battery with an outdated catalogue price gets the price from recent quotes (at least three, from the last 180 days) instead of dropping out. Heat-pump prices older than 180 days get a label and a wider margin; older than a year, they no longer count.
  3. Calculation After confirming a quote you can share its price anonymously (off by default). With enough shared quotes, they add to the fair price ranges, shown with the number of quotes and their months.
  4. Calculation In 'Why the quote says X and we say Y' we name perfect foresight as a cause when a promise seems to rest on it: planning a whole year with prices known only afterwards. Every result now also shows what we measure and what we estimate.
  5. Calculation If you have an electric car, we ask when it usually charges: during the day, in the evening or at night. We then put the car's electricity in those hours. If you don't know, we assume evening charging, as before.
  6. Calculation Gas and electricity prices now come from CBS: the average of fixed and variable contracts in the latest month, with its date. For 2027 and later we assume today's price; the range shows how much it can differ, from how the price changed within a year since 2018. Fill in your own gas and electricity price: new contracts often cost more than the average.
  7. Calculation With a hybrid heat pump the boiler now takes over below +2 °C outside (was 0 °C), the top of what installers set. The gas saving comes out at 63 to 73%, in line with Milieu Centraal (60 to 70% less gas for heating); before, we calculated up to 80%.
  8. Calculation Large homes (a cold-day heat demand above 6.5 kW, about 1,500 m³ of gas a year) are calculated with a typical 6 to 8 kW hybrid instead of 4 to 5 kW.
  9. Products and prices Every heat pump now says whether it runs on 1 phase, 3 phases or both, and its maximum power where known. We ask about your connection (for example 1 × 25 A or 3 × 25 A). If a heat pump doesn't fit your connection, we say so and name what an upgrade costs and how long it takes; those costs count in the payback. With one phase, the first choice stays a 1-phase heat pump, with a second card for upgrading when that pays back sooner.
  10. Calculation No fixed €40 per kW limit for trading any more. We compare a trading promise with the realistic range from our backtest on stored ENTSO-E imbalance prices, with the date of that data; only above the top of that range do we call the promise too high. The guides and the figures page now say so too.
  11. Calculation New in the result: the same battery at three other sizes, and what changes with another electricity price, another contract, or more or less loss in the battery.
  12. Calculation If you didn't know your use or your solar panels, the range is now wider, and the result says what we assumed.
  13. Calculation The verdict follows the range: 'doesn't add up' only when even its top stays well below the promise, 'adds up' only when its bottom reaches the promise.
  14. Calculation Heat pumps in the no-quote advice: a typical 4 to 5 kW hybrid that leaves heating to the boiler below 0 °C and in hours it can't manage alone (hot water and cooking stay on gas), and a full heat pump that delivers enough on a cold day. Every result is a range.
  15. Calculation We calculate solar power at an average of 975 kWh per kWp a year (390 kWh per 400 Wp panel), instead of the sunny year 2023. Differences by region and roof direction stay. Without your own figures, we estimate your usage live from your home: people, panels, dwelling type, building period and label.
  16. Calculation No quote yet: we show which battery or heat pump fits your home, what a fair price is (from installer price lists), and when no battery is the best choice.
  17. Calculation If you don't know something, such as your usage or the number of phases, you can choose “don't know”; we then calculate with an assumption the result names.
  18. Products and prices Every battery on our list now has its own efficiency and standby use, from independent measurements where they exist. Heat pumps use certified test points (Keymark).
  19. Calculation The result shows why the quote names a different amount than we do, split by cause.
  20. Calculation We read uploaded quotes and check the size of your inverter (DC/AC ratio).
  21. Calculation With a meter file, we use your own hourly usage and export.
  22. Calculation Without a meter file, we estimate your hourly usage from your answers, with a likely range.
  23. Calculation Heat-pump subsidies (ISDE and Amstelveen), with their conditions and deadlines.
  24. Calculation The battery no longer plans with knowledge of the future, the power limit at the plug counts, and losses apply per unit. We calculate alternatives in full before we rank them.
  25. Calculation First version of the battery calculation: the battery hour by hour, under the rules for 2026 (net metering) and from 2027 (no net metering).
Technical details

Version of the calculation module: 0.1.0+800638e0e9

Every result shows this version. When the calculation changes, the version changes too, and saved results are calculated again.

Last updated: 4 October 2026.